Grand Orange Lodge of Ireland
  Orange Standard

Northern Ireland Is Not A South Africa

Article 2 ~ February 1998

There has been talk recently of a 'Truth and Reconciliation' Commission being set up in Northern Ireland to seek to establish the facts behind the killings in the Province since the start of the 'Troubles'.

There is a very real chance that such a Commission could be hijacked by the republican movement and turned into yet another means of blackening the Unionist community and seeking to make it feel guilt-ridden.

Ulster Unionist security spokesman Ken Maginnis was right to warn of such a commission being a 'circus' when he was questioned on the B.B.C. Newsnight programme. The apparent astonishment of Jeremy Paxman who put the question will not impress most Ulster people - they will be aware of the ability of republicans to use propaganda in the most skilful manner to cloud issues and also to throw the vast amount of the blame on Unionists.

South Africa was used by those in favour of this course as an example of how such a commission works. Interesting isn't it how South Africa so often figures in comparison to Northern Ireland, yet the analogy is far off the mark. In South Africa a white minority of less than 20 per cent held power for nearly 50 years. In Northern Ireland, a two-thirds Unionist majority is denied the right to run its own affairs in a devolved government.

However, back to the original point, regarding a commission. In South Africa all the available evidence so far points to most of those being examined as being Afrikaners and security force personnel in the former ruling Government. Winnie Mandela is the outstanding exception, but one wonders how many of the 'necklace' burners - those who put lighted tyres around the shoulders of their victims - will be in the dock.

In Northern Ireland people are well aware of how the media, often inspired by republicans, can be used to vilify Protestants and Unionists. Crimes carried out by loyalist groups or individuals are banner-headlined, books are written about the 'Shankill Butchers' and there is a real queue of witnesses about 'Bloody Sunday' in Londonderry, as well as in-depth studies.

How many in-depth studies and books have been written exposing who was behind the atrocity of Bloody Friday in Belfast, or who were the men who murdered the Orangemen at Tullyvallen Orange Hall, those who perpetrated the Kingsmills and Teebane massacres, the murders of Sir Norman Stronge and his son James, the Rev. Robert Bradford, and a long catalogue of republican murders?

Protestants and Unionists are notoriously reluctant to go before the cameras and tell their story, and it could prove to be the same with a 'Truth and Reconciliation Commission'. It could prove to be a means of lambasting the British Army, the R.U.C., and loyalists without the essential balancing on the other side - a 'come clean' on how all the I.R.A. and I.N.L.A. murders were carried out, and the planning which went into the same.

Who for example was commander of the Belfast I.R.A. units who slaughtered so many people on Bloody Friday? Who was the I.R.A. chief in Londonderry when that city was pounded with bombs throughout the I.R.A. bombing campaign of the 1970's and 80's?

Who took the decision to detonate a bomb at the War Memorial in Enniskillen on Remembrance Sunday? Who were the men who butchered innocent worshippers in the Darkley gospel hall in South Armagh?

Back to Back ~ Orange Standard Home ~ Issue Index ~ Previous Article~ Next Article

The Grand Orange Lodge of Ireland
Schomberg House, 368 Cregagh Road, Belfast, BT6 9YE
T: +44 (0) 28 9070 1122 ~ F: +44 (0)28 9040 3700
Buy Online - the best way to buy

© Grand Orange Lodge of Ireland 2002-2006

Site Map

Web Design by www.truska.com